Actually, no, Naarn is not right.
Read my post if you are going to take the time to disagree with it.
1) I never said that anything was impossible.
2) Solo, legitimate plevelling without twinkery and in absolute anonymity happens, but it does not happen at that speed nearly as often as Naarn suggested. Disagree all that you want- but I see the real numbers- you don't.
3) I can guarantee you that a character played by someone like Tragonis will receive different treatment than a character played by someone like Allikat or by a complete n00b or played in complete anonymity when it comes to IC helpfulness of other characters and when it comes to things like consideration for cabals and tribunals. Any of you who deny it are either really naive or simply lying through your teeth. And this different kind of treatment, even if not organized for twinkery, still has significant bearing upon that character's ability to progress quickly.
4) Players who have been around longer and who have learned the system will obviously be at an advantage for faster levelling. They also tend to be more vocal and visible in the OOC arenas. They also tend to think that they are the norm or the majority, when in reality they are rarely either. The
average player, whether a newbie or a veteran, cannot and does not level at the speeds suggested by Naarn.
5) How many characters has Tragonis burned through in the period of time that it took Frollith to reach GM? How many characters has he burned through in that same period of time since Frollith reached GM and has stuck around? While it may SEEM that the plevelling process is easy and common because you've seen 5-6 different characters do it, the reality is that the plevelling players often don't keep their characters as long, they are louder about making themselves known & seen in both IC and OOC arenas, and therefore give a skewed perspective about how prolific this actually is. The true indicator is not how many CHARACTERS are plevelled this way, but how many PLAYERS can plevel this way.
6) Even among the plevelling players whom I like and respect (such as Tragonis for instance), very very very few can make HONEST assertions of playing completely free of twinkery or free of OOC influence that benefits them.
Again, to reiterate, it is this claim that I refuted:
Naarn wrote:
Anyone who knows the game fairly well knows that it's not hard to level any GM 50-75 hrs or less without twinkery anyway.
The above is simply not true. There are a LOT of players who know the game well who CANNOT do this. There are a LOT of players who know the game well who can do this, but not easily as Naarn suggests. And there are a LOT of players who know the game well who can do so only with twinkery and/or the benefit of their OOC reputation.
There is a tremendous difference between what is POSSIBLE and what is "not hard" for "anyone who knows the game fairly well".
I'm quite certain that the facts are on my side in this discussion.