Rodwen wrote:
A 101 year old elf looks like a 16 year old human, and a 275 year old elf looks like a 90 year old human, with pointy ears of course.
All the lower number means is they are fully developed. Once they are fully developed, their "potential productivity" is equal. At least, that's how I see it.
Here's the riddle, though:
An elf is playable for 174 years... that's an elven 'lifetime.'
Humans, 74.
That's about 235% more time out of an elf.
But 16 * 235% yields only about 38.
For elves to basically Double Your Pleasure Plus a Little Extra, they'd theoretically need to be Young at 38 and Venerable at 212. This is not the case. There is a discrepancy. The elven maturation rate either does not follow humans or, if it does, there are additional years spent being indoctrinated in elven culture. Just as a human could theoretically have children and do all 'adult' tasks around, I don't know, 13, so too do elves seem to have suffered from the delayed maturation of societal norms.
tl;dr: elves have major adultescence issues
The numbers are even more pronounced with other races, if I recall.
Personally, I like the third explanation: the age system was added after the MUD was initially developed, so the numbers were arbitrary.