Edoras wrote:
At that point all you're doing is allowing access to the tribunal channel. It seems a bit silly to me.
That would be called a channel to RP with and feel involved with, and thus be 'in' the group without being known to the realms. It's good for that initiation process, and would encourage/increase the probability members of the group would be helping that person train up as they are giving their oath/promise to be serve. It would also be a means for 'secret members,' who can't really do anything, but.. well be those spying type communicators, without giving themselves away (by title, law immunity, guard ordering, etc.)
It would also encourage the new players, or long term newb players to get involved with a tribunal. It promotes inclusiveness. This way you can take someone who may not be 'fit' enough, and get them involved with the poltics and feel as a more experienced vet/leader of the group, they are giving their oath, so what you put into them, likely is going to have an ROI with them becoming a full fledged member.