I just disagree strongly with the idea that we need to come up things to discourage the drive to GM. There's nothing inherently wrong with the desire to speed level. In fact, it's more strange to code in a GM status, and then come up with elaborate schemes to make people feel that it's not so important to work for. I think all of these discussions are a sign that the leveling system isn't favoring SK's desired sort of player. That's the real problem here, not the natural achiever's desire to gain the highest level.
The simple fact is that players will naturally do the things that will get them to GM sooner. If it's grinding and questing, they'll be grinding and questing. If it's RP, they will RP. If it's exploring, they will explore. If it's ganking or cooking and quilting...you get the picture. Whatever behavior the leveling system rewards, it's the sort of player who likes doing it that will reach level 50 sooner.
I guess some of the recent changes have been trying to move in the right direction, but the negative discouragement of grinding on NPCs doesn't address the whole issue. I think in some ways it even makes things worse, because it only deters players that don't have the time, patience, or ability to plevel, therefore the net effect is to tilt the levels more towards those with the will to grind for hours and hours. You can just look at how quickly Bethnai got to GM, for example, to see how expert plevelers are barely fazed by the nerfs.
In the meantime, because the system is ultimately rewarding the twinky people, other people are clamoring for ways to even the field between GM and master. This wouldn't even come up if, say, SK were a grind and gank MUD, or if reaching level 50 actually involved the things that you want players to do.
Dulrik wrote:
While it would be ideal to have a RP requirement to make it to the end levels, the reality just doesn't work. Once it's required, twinks will put on the pressure to get the necessary rewards and then pretty soon all the Paragons will also be twinks and life will go on for them as usual while everyone else just gets more screwed.
I can't think of a way for some twink to get ten rewards that doesn't involve actual RP or nepotism/cheating. The former would be a good thing, and I'm sure the latter would raise red flags amongst the staff, who already monitor paragons. There's a maximum of only 360 PAR rewards in one month, after all, and I suspect the actual number is much smaller.