This isn't the first time I've had trouble with one of these quests, but this is the most recent.
Quote:
Heditch the baker says to you 'I have just finished baking this bread. '
Heditch the baker reaches under the counter and pulls out a stack of freshly baked bread.
Heditch the baker says to you 'Here you are.'
Heditch the baker gives you a loaf of pumpernickel bread.
Heditch the baker says to you 'Hurry and give it to Sellenius before it gets cold.'
{HP: 100%}{ME: 95%}{PE: 95%} 1 platinum, 3 silver, 7 copper
Dark Shades 20, 1052 4pm
>e
---Insert lots of movement---
{HP: 100%}{ME: 95%}{PE: 88%} 1 platinum, 3 silver, 7 copper
Dark Shades 20, 1052 5pm
>give bread sell
You give a loaf of pumpernickel bread to Sellenius.
{HP: 100%}{ME: 95%}{PE: 100%} 1 platinum, 3 silver, 7 copper
Dark Shades 20, 1052 5pm
>
Sellenius raises an eyebrow.
Sellenius says 'I do not need this.'
Sellenius drops a loaf of pumpernickel bread.
The NPCs you have to request the items from give you different items and only specific ones actually complete the quest. I had to go back and ask for bread again to get the proper item to complete the quest.