Edoras wrote:
Killing an opponent is a big enough benefit already to the team doing the killing: Jailtime is already a full loot and in most cases ends in execution anyway. There's a difference between beating an opponent and griefing them: And extensive jailtime really crosses that line.
To put things in perspective, if I were to log off of my character and play an alt until he was executed at the 1/10 rate, then I'd be playing that alt for three months. In the meantime, all the people who played with my character would be one friend short, and I would also be unable to perform any tribunal commands like inducting people. It doesn't really do good for the game, IMO, when people who lose in PvP just log off and start playing their alts instead, which is basically what extensive jailtime encourages per your own statement. No one is asking to make their huge lists of crimes meaningless. They're just acknowledging the fact that -no one- is going to serve an IRL three month sentence. 100% of those people break out of jail. So why not limit it to something more reasonable, like one RL day, at the end of which there's a more debilitating affect like spirit disorientation applied upon release that could last much longer in-game than normal SD?
Long story short: don't grief the law system, and the law system won't grief you.
People can't mock the bounty system and the legal defense system by spam-killing NPCs up to hundreds of days of jail time, maximizing BH spawn rates, and then play the "don't grief me bro" card. It has been your complete choice to rack up the consequences of griefing the law system, knowing full well the outcome. You can't ignore that fact and say you're getting griefed. In reality, you griefed first. This is not an unavoidable aspect of the game that requires changing. It is within your complete control to not get wrecked by the law. If people have a law list like the one you had, those people deserve to be the horror stories. I would argue that all warparties should be buffed dang-near exponentially to make a full party required to jailbreak someone.
Jail time: the real teeth of a system that everyone says is too easy to abuse and dominate, yet without fail the abusers always complain the moment they get bitten.
Characters that rack up lists like that, that can't RP diplomacies to reduce sentencing/gather parole, deserve every last ounce of what they get.