Styles wrote:
Opey wrote:
I don't see any advantage to bring back the hero system. Not one.
It would reward long term character development. It would encourage players with true RPK talent to become more invested in their characters. This would lead to a richer social climate on SK. The Pijouhs and Ithorims would be more than just flashes in the pan. With real gameplay benefits such as those gained from getting to GM+1 and a richer RP culture on SK, you might see people like jerin and baldric actually playing instead of just posting here.
Note that I am not proposing "bringing back the hero system." I don't think there should be all the hoopla around getting to GM+1. You just get the gameplay benefits if you make it there. Nobody will even know it unless you tell them.
I'm sorry if this sounds condescending, but I just can't reword it any other way: you do realize it took me less than 2 weeks after attaining GM to get the ability to advance to GM+1, right? Your proposal leads to none of your stated goals, and would have changed my deletion of him in no way - nor even given me reason to pause in the slightest. If there's no hoopla or anything, then all you've done is effectively raise the level limit by 1, and removed even the limited prestige of the endeavor.
SK has dozens of empirical cases to prove that this sort of artificial slowing down doesn't work. Back in the day, Reina put Toryn on a "leveling diet" of what, 2 levels a day? Guess what he did? 2 levels a day, and not one thing more. No more RP, no more interaction, anything. He just stuck to his leveling diet and went about what he wanted to once he hit GM. The people you'd propose this to affect would act the exact same way, unfortunately. Toryn isn't the only example, just the more readily hilarious one that comes to mind. You create something uninspired that is merely a hoop when you focus on the things you're proposing we focus on.
I'm not trying to limit your creativity or urge you away from the conversation. I appreciate your honesty of opinion and your passion for the game to put it forward. I just whole-heartedly disagree with some of these things. As opey said, the mentor system was proposed and 'does' exactly what you state - and would turn out exactly the same as what you're proposing. An inspired but terribly unimpactful change.