drexalv wrote:
I think the ability to order guards should be changed from one's charisma level to one's level. Charisma is already factored in when considering lag and that's fine. What I can't see is a guard not listening to the leader of their faction just because he's not charismatic.
The best counter-point to this would be that a GM or near GM level guard is on a similar rank as you, even as the GM Justiciar or Captain or whatever rank you possess. Think about it. Gervais has seen countless numbers of Justiciars and Captains come and go, and he'll more than likely outlive whoever the Justiciar or Captain is now. If -anything-, that guy ought to be able to pull rank on whoever he wants.
I guess what I'm trying to say is that maybe tribs with GM level guards ought to be glad that the charisma modifier exists on leadership, because if the charisma bonus didn't come into play then it would be impossible to order around GM level guards period.
Of course, the gameplay argument would be that dumping stats should never be totally free. All characters should lose -something- notable if they dump a stat completely. If charisma was taken away from leadership, then mercs, barbs, priests and shamans would lose even less from low-balling their charisma, which is already a pretty easy stat to dump anyway.