Shattered Kingdoms

I almost didn't include berry/cherry type pies, because those are not Thanksgiving pies, and you shouldn't pick them.

What kind of pie do you think is best on Thanksgiving? And please, if you like a chocolate pecan pie, for instance, include it in the "pecan" pie section. Don't try to cheat here.

Cherry pie is infinitely more Thanksgiving-y than COCONUT, woman.

That said ... I'm a one-small-slice-each-pumpkin-and-pecan kind of girl.

If not warm, pecan.

If warm, apple.

Also wtf, cheesecake.

Is that considered a pie?

This is an age-old debate. I don't know; but I thought I'd include it. I feel at least for Thanksgiving, it would be included among the pies after dinner.

I am about to get rocks thrown at me but...


I don't like cheesecake. It is gross. I like apple pie, though. Where I grew up, there was an apple orchard and some cherry trees. Man, that was good times.

I feel you, opey. I didn't like cheesecake until the last couple years, and am still finicky about it.

You need a "It's pie and I am a fat little piggy" option.

You guys.

I don't like cheesecake either. It's not even that it's the worst; it's just not that great. If I'm going to stuff myself full of cream and sugar and butter and gluten I'd like for it to come in a way that doesn't make me go, meh.

I can't believe we all have so much in common when we all hate each other.

cream